858-943-6591
Call Us Now
Email Us Now
Domestic violence is a complex area of law that often requires navigating two distinct legal systems simultaneously. In California, domestic violence falls under both family law and criminal law, yet these courts operate independently with different goals, standards of proof, and outcomes. Because domestic violence sits at the intersection of these fields, victims and defendants often face conflicting court orders and complex litigation. Understanding the specific roles of each court is the first step in protecting your rights and safety.
Legal Context: In California, domestic violence is considered both a civil family matter and a criminal offense. Family Law addresses immediate safety through restraining orders and impacts on child custody, while Criminal Law focuses on punishing the offender through charges like Domestic Battery (PC 243(e)(1)) or Corporal Injury on a Spouse (PC 273.5).
Divorce and Domestic Violence: The Intersection of Law
A couple that never before had an issue with domestic violence may suddenly experience abusive or violent behaviors during a divorce. Divorces are naturally a volatile time in a relationship and can trigger abusive or threatening behaviors that did not previously exist or were not apparent. A spouse may become physically violent and strike, push, or sexually assault a partner out of anger or spite. A spouse may also resort to stalking, intimidating, or bullying an intimate partner to get what they want, such as certain assets or custody of children.
In some cases, one spouse may falsely allege domestic violence to obtain an advantage in child custody. Under California Family Code 3044, there is a legal presumption that awarding custody to a parent with a history of domestic violence is not in the child’s best interest. Because of this, a defendant facing false allegations needs a criminal defense attorney to prevent a criminal record that could permanently terminate their parental rights. Without a skilled attorney, the defendant risks losing custody and facing significant social stigma.
Family Court vs. Criminal Court: Key Differences
Many individuals mistakenly believe that family and criminal courts use the same rules to decide a domestic violence case. However, each court has an entirely separate process. The family court system focuses on resolution and protection within the family unit, whereas the criminal court system focuses on accountability and punishment for a crime against the state.
The goal of family court is to allow two parties to resolve personal differences in front of a neutral third party. In these proceedings, the state holds little power, and each party is responsible for their own legal representation. Criminal court, on the other hand, utilizes the power of the state (the District Attorney) to prosecute the defendant. Because criminal court views domestic violence as an offense against the public, the state can continue a case even if the victim decides they no longer wish to press charges.
Legal Protections and Standards of Proof
Family law proceedings operate on the underlying assumption that a family dispute is a civil matter. Therefore, the burden of proof is usually a “preponderance of the evidence” (meaning it is more likely than not that the abuse occurred). In contrast, criminal court requires “proof beyond a reasonable doubt,” a much higher standard because the defendant’s physical liberty and constitutional rights are at stake.
In criminal court, the accused cannot launch counter-allegations against the victim. The defendant can only defend against the specific charges brought by the state. This structure often makes the criminal process feel more protective for the victim. Victims can also request a Criminal Protective Order (CPO), which typically takes precedence over any conflicting Domestic Violence Restraining Orders (DVRO) issued in family court. These orders can include no-contact provisions, move-out orders, and the mandatory surrendering of firearms.
If you are involved in a dispute that involves violent behavior in San Diego, it is vital to contact a domestic violence lawyer who understands how a criminal charge will impact your family law standing. Protecting your rights requires a defense that addresses both sides of the legal spectrum.
Common Questions: Is Domestic Violence Criminal or Family Law?
- Can I have cases in both courts at once? Yes. It is common to have a family law case for custody or divorce while a criminal case for domestic battery is pending.
- Which court order is more important? Generally, a Criminal Protective Order (CPO) takes precedence over a family court restraining order if the terms conflict.
- Will a criminal conviction affect my divorce? Yes. Convictions can impact spousal support eligibility and create a legal presumption against you in custody hearings.